Print
 

  MIG Update – September 23, 2024



Reliance on Symptom Magnification Test Proves Fatal

This week a MIG escape on the basis of psychological impairment. The mva in question occurred in 2019 with all relevant expert opinions provided proximate to one another a few months later. The Tribunal considered the psychological tests the experts selected and their resulting differing conclusions of the expert opinions in making its determination.



Virtual Training – Fall Sessions!

Secure your seat for inHEALTH’s 2024 Fall Virtual Training sessions!

  • SABS Expedited: October 7th – 11th, 2024
  • BI Fundamentals: November 4th – 8th, 2024

*Eligible Participants receive 9 Substantive – CPD hours upon course completion

Course details & register here +



Factor: Expert Opinion

In John v. Economical Insurance Company (21-014025) Stephon John was involved in a motor vehicle accident on March 2, 2019, and sought entitlement to five OCF-18s for chiropractic treatment, physiotherapy and orthopaedic and psychological assessments totaling $10,518.57. John claimed she sustained a psychological impairment and should not be held within the MIG.

John relied on the July 2019 opinion from psychologist, Ms. Aghamohseni, who concluded that John met the criteria for Major Depressive Disorder, Single Episode, Somatic Symptom Disorder and Specific Phobia, situational type, vehicular.

Economical argued that John’s injuries fell within the minor injury definition relying on two IE reports, one in August 2019 IE report of psychologist, Dr. Rubenstein who found no evidence that warranted any diagnosis according to DSM-IV. The second, an addendum in March 2020 also by Dr. Rubenstein who didn’t agree with Ms.Aghamohseni opinion because it was based on John’s self report.




The Tribunal found:

    • The report of psychologist Ms. Aghamohseni dated July 2019, which was comprehensive and persuasive and supported her conclusions of a psychological diagnosis under the DSM-V. She administered five psychological tests as follows:
    • Beck Depression Inventory–II (BDI-II); score of 46 – severe depression
    • Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI): score of 32 – severe anxiety
    • Davidson Trauma Scale (DTS): difficulties ranging from “A little bit” to “Extremely”
    • Pain Patient Profile (P-3): average or above average difficulties and
    • Symptom Checklist 90-R (SCL-90-R): mild through severe difficulties
    • “I assign less weight to the report of Dr. Rubenstein. In that assessment, the applicant completed a Pain Patient Profile (P-3) test whose results were consistent with the test administered by Ms. Aghamohseni. Dr. Rubenstein noted that the results “might suggest clinically significant levels of affective and somatic distress”. In the face of that conclusion, Dr. Rubenstein then relies on a Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS) test which he says makes it “difficult if not impossible to lend validity to other test scores”. Rather than administer any of the other standard psychological tests, Dr. Rubenstein jumped right to a test designed to show an applicant is feigning or exaggerating symptoms, which in my view makes his report less compelling.”
    • ”In an addendum report dated March 30, 2020 Dr. Rubenstein stated that the diagnosis of Ms. Aghamohseni was not adequately supported as it relied “almost exclusively on the subjective reporting of the claimant”. I disagree with that conclusion as the diagnosis was based on five psychological tests which are designed to measure psychological symptoms. By their very design, a psychological test requires input from the individual being tested.”


If you Have Read This Far…

Our MIG Monday series discusses the multitude of factors to consider when evaluating a risk position on MIG cases. The Tribunal has ruled on the MIG in 24% of the decisions so far. Each case is nuanced, but with similar factors.

Inform your position & present persuasive arguments. Include an Outcome Analysis Report (OAR) in your case evaluation complete with For/Against cases. Need an OAR?

 

Archive of LAT Updates

December 18, 2024: Applicant Successful in CAT Case Where Respondent’s Expert Unavailable

CAT

December 16, 2024: Applicants Lose on Flawed Interpretation of the Schedule

MIG

December 11, 2024: Court Sends Paraplegic Matter Back to Tribunal re “Accident”

Definition Accident, Divisional Court, Reconsiderations

December 9, 2024: Pre-Existing Conditions MIG Escapes?

MIG

December 4, 2024: Court Remits $770K Award Worthy Matter Back to Tribunal

Award, Divisional Court, IRB

December 2, 2024: GP Questionnaire Does Not Trigger MIG Escape on Pre Existing

MIG

November 27, 2024: Court Remits $200K Award Worthy Matters Back to Tribunal

Award, Divisional Court, IRB

November 25, 2024: Pre-Screen Not Psychological Diagnosis

MIG

November 20, 2024: IE Not Reasonable or Necessary – No to CAT & IRB

CAT, IRB, Procedure

November 18, 2024: No Evidence Pre-Existing Conditions Prevent MMR

MIG

November 13, 2024: Applicant’s Explanation for Delayed Application Found Reasonable

Procedure

November 11, 2024: GP Concussion Diagnosis Accepted as Legitimate

MIG

November 6, 2024: Court Remits “Unsafe” Decision Back for Rehearing

CAT

November 4, 2024: Submissions Do Not = Evidence

MIG

October 30, 2024: Court Remits “Unsafe” Decision Back for Rehearing

CAT, Divisional Court

October 28, 2024: IE Fails to Explain Lack of Diagnosis

MIG

October 23, 2024: Loose Lid Unexpected "Accident"

Definition Accident

October 21, 2024: Dental Work Required Not Caused by MVA

MIG

October 7, 2024: Continuity of Complaints Confirm Chronic Pain

MIG

October 2, 2024: All Items in Dispute Deemed Incurred

Treatment Plans

September 30, 2024: Ignoring Medical Evidence Proves Award Worthy

MIG

September 25, 2024: Credibility Issues Abound with IE Assessor

IE

September 23, 2024: Reliance on Symptom Magnification Test Proves Fatal

MIG

September 16, 2024: Self Reporting Accepted for Psych MIG Escape

MIG

September 9, 2024: Diagnosis Alone Falls Short in Chronic Pain Case

MIG

September 4, 2024: CAT Finding Upheld on Reconsideration

CAT, Reconsiderations

August 28, 2024: Staged MVA Results in $93K Repayment Order

Definition Accident, Evidence

August 26, 2024: What Exactly Constitutes “Compelling” Evidence?

MIG

August 21, 2024: Extreme Impairment Confirmed in CAT Decision

CAT

August 19, 2024: Post Concussive Syndrome Diagnosed in Telephone Interview

MIG

August 14, 2024: Reconsideration Varies Decision Regarding “Accident”

Definition Accident, Divisional Court

August 12, 2024: Adverse Inference Considered in MIG Determination

MIG

August 7, 2024: Re-Training Not A Viable Option - Post 104 IRB Confirmed

IRB

July 31, 2024: Applicants Allowed to Proceed to Hearing Despite Alleged Non – Compliance

Insurer’s Examinations, Procedure

July 29, 2024: No Specific Reference to Evidence Precludes MIG Escape

MIG

July 24, 2024: When is a Spouse Not a “Spouse”?

Death Benefit

July 22, 2024: No Evidence Tendered to Rebut Concussion Diagnosis

MIG

July 17, 2024: 196K Grievance Award Factored into IRB Calculation

IRB

July 15, 2024: Chronic Pain Diagnosis Does Not Warrant MIG Escape

MIG

July 10, 2024: Court Allows Applicant to Submit Judicial Review After the Fact

Divisional Court

July 8, 2024: MIG Escape Despite Unrelated Psych Issues

MIG

July 3, 2024:Application Premature On Benefits Claimed in Excess of Limits

Award, CAT, Jurisdiction

June 26, 2024: Multiple Wilful Misrepresentations Claimed but Only One Established

IRB

June 24, 2024: Chronic Pain Diagnosis 4 Years Later Uncontroverted

MIG

June 19, 2024: Court Sets Aside Tribunal Decision and Makes Decision that Ought to Have Been Made

Definition Accident, Divisional Court

June 17, 2024: Cause of ‘Remote’ Finger Fracture Questioned

MIG

June 10, 2024: Reliability on IE Opinions Challenged

MIG

June 5, 2024: IE 'Highly Intrusive' - Not Acceptable Reason For Failure To Attend

Insurer's Examinations

June 3, 2024: MVA Necessary Cause of Subluxation of Shoulder Joint

MIG

May 29, 2024: Practicing Lawyer Seeks CAT Determination

CAT

May 27, 2024: Differing Opinions on Right Knee Injury Causation

MIG

May 22, 2024: Four Marked Impairments CAT and Post 104 IRB Confirmed

CAT, IRB

May 15, 2024: Court Confirms Three Breaches of Procedural Fairness by Tribunal

Div Court

May 13, 2024: Little Weight Given to Illegible Doctor's Notes

MIG

May 8, 2024: Reasonable Perception of Bias Involving Former Adjudicator Requires Rehearing

Reconsideration

May 6, 2024: Potential Causation Does Not Support MIG Escape

MIG

May 1, 2024: Tribunal Varies Three Decisions on Reconsideration

Reconsideration, Treatment Plans

April 29, 2024: Credibility of Assessment Favored Over Psych Validity Testing

MIG

April 24, 2024: Wilful Misrepresentation Abounds on IRB Repayments

IRB

April 22, 2024: Records Alone Do Not Warrant MIG Removal on Pre-Existing

MIG

April 15, 2024: Demands of Child-birth Pre-Existing Condition?

MIG