Print
 

MIG Update – January 25, 2021



Concussion

Head injuries, such as concussion and post-concussive syndrome, if established, fall outside the MIG. In this week’s edition, we report on two similar fact situations where both Applicants reportedly complained of headaches to their family doctors one month post-accident.

The distinction being the presence or absence of corroborating objective evidence.



Factor: Concussion – Considerations for a MIG Escape

In P.S.v Wawanesa (19-003983), a MIG ‘escape’ ruling, P.S.’s vehicle was hit by a car on the passenger side. He did not lose consciousness but reportedly immediately felt pain on the right side of his body and in his head. He visited his family physician complaining of headaches, neck pain and neurocognitive symptoms one month post-accident, with objective testing leading to a diagnosis of concussion.

The Tribunal held that P.S. sustained concussion and ongoing concussion-related injuries that remove him from the MIG:

  • A Sport Concussion Assessment Test – 3rd Edition (“SCAT3”) was performed by the family doctor, indicating a concussion
  • Ongoing pain and headaches were noted by the family doctor as well as the IE assessor
  • No loss of consciousness and a normal brain CT scan do not negate the diagnosis of concussion through the SCAT3 test


In P.S. v Wawanesa (18-008980), a MIG ‘hold’ ruling, P.S.’s vehicle was stopped at a red light when the impact of a collision sent one of the vehicles into P.S.’s vehicle. P.S. submitted that someone does not have to hit their head on an object to experience a concussion and that he was diagnosed with post-concussive syndrome by his family doctor.

The Tribunal held that P.S. did not suffer from a head injury or post-concussive syndrome:

  • Records from the ER on the date of the accident indicate no complaint of any head injury or concussion
  • The only complaint of symptoms of post-concussive syndrome was not until one month post-accident to the family doctor
  • P.S.’s neurologist did not find any accident-related head injury 6 months post-accident. Instead, P.S. reported only an exacerbation of pre-existing headaches


If you Have Read This Far…

Our MIG Monday series discusses the multitude of factors to consider when evaluating a risk position on MIG cases. The Tribunal has ruled on the MIG in 24% of the decisions so far. Each case is nuanced, but with similar factors.

Include an Outcome Analysis Report (OAR) in your case evaluation complete with For/Against cases similar to your fact situation to inform your position & present persuasive arguments. Need an OAR?

 

Archive of LAT Updates

July 21, 2025: Provisional PTSD Diagnosis Suffices for MIG Escape

MIG

June 4, 2025: MIG Escape Justifies CAT Assessments

CAT, MIG

June 2, 2025: Late Onset (Two Years) Shoulder Pain Remains in MIG

MIG

May 28, 2025: CRA Records not Necessarily Determinative Absent Corroborating Documentation

IRB

May 26, 2025: Insomnia a Pre-Existing Condition

MIG

May 16, 2025: First Year of Self Employment Results in $Nil IRB Despite Demonstrated Earnings

IRB

May 12, 2025: Res Judicata Not Waived For New MIG Hearing

MIG

April 30, 2025: Tribunal Confirms Four Class 4 Marked Impairments

CAT

April 28, 2025: MIG Not Conceded Despite Approved CAT Assessments

MIG

April 23, 2025: Court Reverses Tribunal’s Unreasonable Adjournment Refusal

Adjournment, CAT, Divisional Court

April 21, 2025: MIG Escape on Fractured Tooth 15 Months Later

MIG

April 16, 2025: Deficient Notice Renders NEB Payable

NEB

April 14, 2025: MIG Valid Medical Reason

MIG

April 9, 2025: Bus Travelling Over Elevated Manhole Cover Satisfies “Collision”

Definition Accident

April 7, 2025: Four OCF 18’s Payable Despite MIG Hold

MIG

March 26, 2025: Post 104 IRB Ongoing for Non-CAT

CAT, IRB

March 24, 2025: 30% Award for Failure to Review CNRs Overturned on Reconsideration

MIG

March 19, 2025: Yes to CAT, No to Post 104 IRB

CAT, IRB

March 17, 2025: Imaging Report Alone Insufficient to Establish Causation

MIG

March 12, 2025: Tribunal Rules Again on Matter Referred Back by the Court

Definition Accident, Divisional Court

March 10, 2025: Res Judicata Waived on New Evidence

MIG

March 5, 2025: No Criterion 8 CAT as Physical Pain the Limiting Factor

CAT

March 3, 2025: Cause of Shoulder Tear Degenerative or MVA Related?

MIG

February 26, 2025: NEB Payable to 104 Week Mark Due to Technical Breaches

NEB

February 24, 2025: Doctor Not Required to Provide Diagnosis

MIG

February 19, 2025: Court Sets Aside Tribunal S.32 Notice Decision

Breaking News, Div Court, Limitation Period

February 12, 2025: Post 104 IRB Despite Employment & No CAT As Only Two Marked Impairments

CAT, IRB

February 10, 2025: GP Evidence Preferred over IE Regarding Concussion

MIG

February 5, 2025: No Election Required Despite Endorsement of IRB & NEB

Procedure, SABS

January 27, 2025: CNR’s + Imaging Determinative of Complete Shoulder Tear

MIG

January 22, 2025: Court of Appeal Upholds Divisional Court Decision

Divisional Court, NEB, Reconsideration

January 20, 2025: GP’s Diagnosis of “Head Injury” Prevails

MIG

January 15, 2025: Tribunal Accepts Neither Expert in Awarding Pre But Not Post 104 IRB

IRB

January 13, 2025: A Brain Contusion is Not Enough for a Concussion Diagnosis

MIG

January 9, 2025: Court Awards $69K in Costs for Apparent Miscarriage of Justice

Divisional Court,Costs

January 6, 2025: Corroborative Evidence Not Necessarily Required in Psych Diagnoses

MIG

December 18, 2024: Applicant Successful in CAT Case Where Respondent’s Expert Unavailable

CAT

December 16, 2024: Applicants Lose on Flawed Interpretation of the Schedule

MIG

December 11, 2024: Court Sends Paraplegic Matter Back to Tribunal re “Accident”

Definition Accident, Divisional Court, Reconsiderations

December 9, 2024: Pre-Existing Conditions MIG Escapes?

MIG

December 4, 2024: Court Remits $770K Award Worthy Matter Back to Tribunal

Award, Divisional Court, IRB

December 2, 2024: GP Questionnaire Does Not Trigger MIG Escape on Pre Existing

MIG

November 27, 2024: Court Remits $200K Award Worthy Matters Back to Tribunal

Award, Divisional Court, IRB

November 25, 2024: Pre-Screen Not Psychological Diagnosis

MIG

November 20, 2024: IE Not Reasonable or Necessary – No to CAT & IRB

CAT, IRB, Procedure

November 18, 2024: No Evidence Pre-Existing Conditions Prevent MMR

MIG

November 13, 2024: Applicant’s Explanation for Delayed Application Found Reasonable

Procedure

November 11, 2024: GP Concussion Diagnosis Accepted as Legitimate

MIG

November 6, 2024: Court Remits “Unsafe” Decision Back for Rehearing

CAT

November 4, 2024: Submissions Do Not = Evidence

MIG